Comprehension : Comprehension

Q 396 / 466

UPSC CSE Prelims 2012

In a typical Western liberal context, deepening of democracy invariably leads to consolidation of ‘liberal values’. In the Indian context, democratization is translated into greater involvement of people not as ‘individuals’ which is a staple to liberal discourse, but as communities or groups. Individuals are getting involved in the public sphere not as ‘atomized’ individuals but as members of primordial communities drawn on religious or caste identity. Community-identity seems to be the governing force. It is not therefore surprising that the so-called peripheral groups continue to maintain their identities with reference to the social groups (caste, religion or sect) to which they belong while getting involved in the political processes despite the fact that their political goals remain more or less identical. By helping to articulate the political voice of the mariginalized, democracy in India has led to ‘a loosening of social strictures’ and empowered the peripherals to be confident of their ability to improve the socio-economic conditions in which they are placed. This is a significant political process that had led to a silent revolution through a meaningful transfer of power from the upper caste elites to various subaltern groups within the democratic framework of public governance.

According to the passage, what does ‘deepening of democracy’ mean in the Western context?

EXPLANATION

Correct Option (d)

The passage explicitly states that in a typical Western liberal context, "deepening of democracy invariably leads to consolidation of ‘liberal values’". None of the options (a), (b), or (c) directly reflect this specific definition provided for the Western context. Therefore, option (d) is the correct choice as the other statements do not accurately represent the passage's definition of 'deepening of democracy' in the Western context.

Incorrect Options:

  • Option (a) - "Consolidation of group and class identities": The passage describes the involvement of people as "communities or groups" based on religious or caste identity in the Indian context, not as the outcome of 'deepening of democracy' in the Western liberal context.
  • Option (b) - "Democratization translated greater involvement of people": This statement is a general observation about democratization, specifically mentioned in the Indian context where it leads to greater involvement of people as communities or groups. It does not define what 'deepening of democracy' means in the Western context according to the passage.
  • Option (c) - "Democratization as greater Involvement of ‘atomized’ individuals in the public sphere": While the concept of 'atomized' individuals is mentioned as a "staple to liberal discourse", the passage defines 'deepening of democracy' in the Western context as the "consolidation of ‘liberal values’". The involvement of 'atomized' individuals is not presented as the direct meaning of 'deepening of democracy' in the Western context, and the passage contrasts this with the Indian context where individuals are not involved as 'atomized' individuals.